Back to the journal

How Hydrophones Detect Killer Whales in BC Waters

A passive hydrophone suspended underwater from a cable in coastal BC, plausible generic equipment

A hydrophone is an underwater microphone. In British Columbia, researchers use hydrophones to record sounds that may include killer whale calls, whistles and echolocation clicks. If a signal is clear enough and matches known recordings, it can help identify a species or group, even when people cannot see the whales. One receiver usually tells you what it heard at its own location, rather than the exact number or position of animals. Researchers compare sound with sighting records, recording conditions and, where available, other stations. A quiet recording can mean the whales were elsewhere, were silent or were difficult to detect. OrcaLab acoustic research

Follow the sound from the water to the recording

When an animal makes a sound underwater, the signal travels through the water. Some of it may reach a hydrophone. The instrument converts changes in pressure into an electrical signal that can be recorded. The recorder, settings and position all affect what ends up in the file. If you listen to a live stream, you are hearing the sound that reached one receiver and passed through that system. The recording can be informative even though it captures only one part of a much larger area. Note the station before interpreting the sound.

The underwater scene contains other sounds as well. A recorder can pick up vessels, waves and other animals. Some signals stand out clearly, while others are faint or overlap. A researcher can listen and also look at a spectrogram, a visual display of sound energy across time and frequency. A repeated shape can help distinguish a possible call from surrounding noise. The display also gives listeners a way to compare recordings that may sound similar on a speaker.

The quality of a recording is part of the evidence. A strong signal may give the researcher more features to compare. A weak signal may show only part of the pattern. If a public feed is compressed, interrupted or hard to hear, keep that in mind before drawing conclusions. The research team may have access to a longer or clearer original. OrcaLab projects and network

What counts as a detection?

A sound first has to be distinguishable from other signals. Researchers then assess what it could be. A patterned call may be consistent with a known killer whale call type. A recording can also be too brief or noisy to identify. An uncertain detection is useful when it is labelled as such. It can be checked against other recordings or against observations made at the same time.

Identification can happen at several levels. A researcher might be confident that killer whales were heard but unable to say which population was present. A call pattern documented for a known group can support a more specific identification. A single sound is unlikely to reveal which individual made it. If other whales were present or out of view, the link between the sound and the group needs care.

A strong record keeps the time, station and interpretation together. If you listen to a clip that has been shared without those details, you can still describe what you hear. It will be harder to decide whether it represents the group named in a caption. Look for the research team's own notes or a record of which animals were identified nearby.

Fixed stations can keep listening after a sighting ends

A shore-based station can record when a whale is outside a person's view or when nobody is looking from the beach. OrcaLab uses a network of hydrophones in parts of the northern Vancouver Island region. Different stations hear different areas and have different conditions. Together, a network can add information about when signals are detected at several places. The data can support research over many days or seasons.

If a similar sound appears at two stations, timing matters. Researchers consider whether it might be the same signal, the same whales moving or separate sounds that are similar. The receiver locations and the conditions affect that interpretation. A simple list of stations with detections is valuable, but it does not automatically give a route or an exact position. Estimating where a sound originated requires a method suited to the instruments and data.

Monitoring over time can help reveal when a population uses a region. To interpret a gap, ask whether the station was working and how often it recorded. A quiet evening when the equipment was working is different from an evening for which there is no data. The question is still detection, not whether every whale in the area made a sound. Monitoring programmes need to account for both the instruments and the behaviour of the animals.

Compare sounds with photographs and field notes

A fin photograph can identify an individual if the necessary markings are clear. A hydrophone can record a known call pattern when the animal is underwater or out of sight. Observers may also note where whales were moving and how many were visible. These records can support one another when they were gathered at relevant times and places. OrcaLab describes using visual observations, photo identification and acoustics together in its research.

Imagine that people photographed a known group travelling through a channel and a nearby station recorded a distinctive call at about the same time. The photo record gives the listener context for interpreting the sound. If several groups were passing, the researchers may need more information to decide who produced it. If the time difference was substantial, the recording could represent another encounter. Keep the uncertainty visible when you describe the result.

Some questions are better answered by one record than the other. For the identity of an individual, a clear photograph may provide more detail. For the time a known call was heard overnight, a fixed recorder can provide an observation people would otherwise miss. For the whales' direction, observers may need a visual or other suitable method. A strong interpretation uses the evidence that matches the question.

Why silence is difficult to interpret

An animal has to produce a signal, the sound has to reach the receiver, and the recording has to be clear enough to distinguish. A quiet interval can occur when any of those things fails. Whales may be absent, may pass silently or may be too far away to detect. Vessel noise or other sound can also obscure a signal. A listener who hears nothing cannot usually say which explanation applies from the feed alone. Pacific marine mammal management framework

A positive detection also has limits. You can hear a sound without knowing where the animal is. It may be beyond your view, and the received loudness does not necessarily reveal the distance. If the question is whether an area was used over a season, researchers can combine repeated detections with the conditions in which they were collected. If the question is where the animal is right now, a short clip may be insufficient.

When comparing records from different sites, look at how they were collected. One station may cover a narrow channel and another more exposed waters. The sounds that reach them can differ even when the same kind of whale is present. A count of detections is easiest to interpret when the authors explain the equipment, the time it was active and what they counted as a detection.

Listen to an example without overreading it

Start with an OrcaLab feed or recording and find the station and time if the information is provided. Listen once for the obvious sounds. On a second pass, note whether they repeat and whether there is noise at the same time. If the source describes the encounter, compare your impressions with its explanation. A call you thought was close may be identified only at the level of a group or population. That difference is worth noticing. OrcaLab live streams

You might also compare two sections of a recording. If one is quiet and the other contains a repeated sound, describe the change. Then ask what else changed. Did the sound of a boat increase or decrease? Did the source mention another station or visual observation? It is easy to assume a new sound marks the arrival of an animal. There may be enough evidence to support that interpretation, or the record may show only that it became detectable.

Keep the source with any excerpt you share. A clip with a date, station and research description helps another person understand what they are hearing. A short unattributed audio file can be harder to interpret. Avoid claiming that you know where the whales are based on what you heard, especially if the recording is delayed or archived.

Ask about the tour hydrophone in Campbell River

Eagle Eye lists a hydrophone on its six-hour whale watching tour. Ask the guide when they can use it and what the crew can hear in the conditions on the day. A short listening session can introduce you to the way underwater sound differs from what you hear on deck. It may include calls, other sounds or a quiet interval. Follow the crew's directions about when to listen and where you can move. Eagle Eye six-hour whale watching

If a call is audible, ask whether they can identify the kind of whale, a known group or only a likely signal. The guide may describe how the sound fits what they saw. If no whale is in view, ask what other evidence would help. You can learn a lot about the limits of a recording without needing a confirmed identification. Eagle Eye's Campbell River orca guide

Check how a report defines a detection interval

Some monitoring records describe a time interval containing calls. That is different from counting individual calls or identifying how many whales produced them. If a table lists several detections, check whether consecutive intervals could belong to the same group passing a station. A report that explains the time unit and classification criteria gives you enough context to compare one day with another. If you want to know whether a species used the region, those detections may be useful even without an exact count. If you want an estimate of abundance, look for a study designed to answer that question and examine how it handled animals that may have gone undetected.

Frequently asked questions

Can a hydrophone count whales?

It records sound. It can detect multiple signals, but those could come from one or several animals. A group estimate generally needs other evidence, such as observations or a study method that can distinguish the sources.

Does a louder call mean the whale was closer?

Loudness can depend on how the animal called, which way it was facing, how the sound travelled and where the receiver was. Distance can matter, but loudness alone usually leaves other possibilities open.

Can I tell the location from a single station?

A single receiver provides evidence that sound reached its location. Estimating where the animal was requires more information and an appropriate method. A network can help researchers compare detections, but the conclusions depend on the data available.

What if I cannot hear anything on a live feed?

Check the source's information about the station and conditions. The feed may be quiet for several reasons, including a lack of detectable sounds from whales. If you want to hear a documented example, use an archived clip with context.

On a Campbell River trip, compare the view above water with what the guide can observe or hear below it. Each part of the encounter can be interesting even when the two cannot be matched exactly.