Back to the journal

How Killer Whale Pods Use Different Calls

Distant orca pod surfacing in Pacific coastal waters, no invented sound visualization

Resident killer whale pods in British Columbia use recurring sets of calls that researchers describe as vocal dialects. Related or regularly associated groups can share call types, while other groups have different repertoires. Researchers compare recordings made during encounters with whales they can identify, often using dorsal fin and saddle patch photographs alongside the sound. A dialect can help connect a recording with a known group. It doesn't give listeners a translation of every call. On a Campbell River trip, ask what a guide can recognise in the sound and how certain the identification is. Ford’s study of resident killer whale calls

A dialect is a pattern across many calls

When researchers describe a killer whale dialect, they are looking at patterns across recordings. A call type is a form of sound that recurs and can be compared with other examples. A repertoire is the set of call types documented for a group. Two pods might share some call types while differing in others. Researchers also look at how a familiar call varies, because the same general pattern can have differences that become visible when many recordings are compared.

That is more specific than saying each pod sounds a little different. A researcher can ask which calls occurred, whether the same pattern is heard again, which animals were present and whether a neighbouring group makes a similar call. If the encounter involved several groups at once, the answer may take more work. Researchers need recordings and observations that let them compare sounds to known whales rather than relying only on location.

A field guide can help you recognise the idea without expecting you to identify a pod. Think about how a repeated melody stands out after you hear it several times. You might learn to recognise its contour even when some notes are quieter or harder to hear. Researchers use tools to compare the details more carefully, and they test a possible match against other sounds. The comparison is with a known pattern, not with a guess about what the animal meant.

Calls, whistles and clicks answer different questions

A recording can contain several kinds of sound. Calls may have a repeated shape that researchers compare across groups. Whistles are another part of the acoustic repertoire and can also show recurring patterns. A published study of Southern Residents documented stereotyped whistles, meaning whistles with recognisable patterns that recurred. That finding adds detail to the way scientists describe killer whale sound. It doesn't make every whistle a group marker or every recording easy to classify. Study of Southern Resident whistles

Echolocation clicks are short signals used to gain information from echoes. They address a different question from whether a group shares a distinctive call repertoire. A single recording can include clicks, calls, background noise and other animals. Scientists can examine the forms and timing of those sounds to decide what is likely to be present. As a listener, try to describe what you hear before assigning a category. A sequence of short pulses and a longer sound are observations you can compare with the source's explanation.

Sound can also change with the setting. A recorder may pick up a call clearly when whales pass close enough, and less clearly as they travel farther away. Vessel noise or other sound can make it difficult to hear parts of a signal. A faint recording does not tell you whether the animal was calling softly or whether the signal simply arrived at the recorder that way. Ask whether the source knows which whales were present and how the recording was made. OrcaLab acoustic monitoring

How pods and acoustic clans are related

Resident killer whales are organised around maternal family lines. Related family groups may travel together in groupings called pods. An acoustic clan groups pods whose call repertoires have features in common. In Canada's recovery strategy, Northern Residents are grouped into A, G and R acoustic clans. Southern Residents belong to one acoustic clan and comprise J, K and L pods. The letter conventions make sense when you know which level and population the source is describing. Canadian resident killer whale recovery strategy

Shared calls can suggest relationships worth investigating. If pods use related forms, researchers can compare those patterns with records of which whales associate and how the groups have changed over time. A call pattern does not establish every individual in the group. A pod is made of many animals, and only some may be calling in a particular recording. Photographs or direct observations add information about who was there.

Researchers also investigate how vocal traditions develop and persist. Work on killer whale vocal learning supports the ability to learn aspects of vocal behaviour. A group repertoire still reflects a complex history, including who associates and what has been recorded. If a source describes a difference between two groups, look at the observations before assuming that the difference appeared in one generation or came from one individual. Study of killer whale vocal learning

How a recording gets connected with known whales

First, researchers need a recording with useful signal and a record of the encounter. A hydrophone is a microphone designed for underwater sound. A fixed hydrophone can record when no boat is close to the whales. During a field encounter, observers may also photograph fins and saddle patches so they can compare the whales with catalogues. Timing matters. A photograph from one part of the day cannot establish that the same animals made a call recorded hours later.

Next, researchers can look at a spectrogram, which displays sound energy across time and frequency. Repeated calls may show recognisable shapes even when there are slight differences between examples. Compare this with hearing an unfamiliar recording once. Your ears can tell you that a sound rose or fell, while the visual display gives you a way to compare when those changes happened and what frequencies they involved. Researchers also look at whether other noise overlaps the call.

Finally, they compare the signal with known examples and the context. If a group was photographed and a distinctive pattern appeared at the same time, the combined record can support an identification. If several groups were present and the signal is common to more than one, the interpretation may remain open. A good account explains the strength of the evidence and what other information would help.

Listen to a clip with a question in mind

Choose a recording from a research group and check whether it is live or archived. Find the location and any description of the encounter. On your first pass, listen for the timing and shape of sounds. Ask whether a particular pattern repeats or changes. On the second pass, compare what you heard with the notes from the source. You might notice that the sound you thought was one call is a sequence of several sounds.

If a live feed is quiet, think about what that tells you. You are listening to what the hydrophone received at that moment. Whales may be elsewhere, may be silent or may be present at a distance where their sounds aren't clear. Other noise may make the signals hard to detect. If the recording is loud, the source may still be out of sight. Avoid assigning an individual or pod until the context supports it. OrcaLab live streams

Try comparing a clip accompanied by a clear sighting record with a clip for which the source gives no identification. The first lets you see how the researchers tied the sound to what they observed. The second may still let you compare sound shapes, but it gives you less basis for naming the whales. This is the same difference a naturalist may describe during a trip when the crew can hear an animal without clearly seeing it.

What to ask on a whale watching trip

If the guide uses a hydrophone, ask what kinds of signals the group is hearing. You can ask whether they recognise a call type or whether they are still deciding what the sound came from. A good question is, “Did you identify those whales from their appearance, their calls or both?” That gives the guide room to explain what was possible on that day. Listen for the difference between identifying a species and recognising a particular group. Eagle Eye Campbell River orca guide

Eagle Eye lists a hydrophone among the equipment for its six-hour whale watching trip. Its use and what it picks up depend on the encounter and conditions. You can also listen to archived research recordings before the trip to practise recognising a few broad sound patterns. That way, even if the hydrophone is quiet on the day, you have another way to understand the guide's explanation. Follow the crew's instructions while listening and watching. Six-hour Campbell River whale watching tour

Compare two recordings before deciding they sound alike

Imagine two clips contain a sound that rises in pitch and then ends abruptly. In one clip you hear the same pattern four times. In the other it appears once, partly covered by another sound. You can describe a similarity, but the clearer recording gives you more detail to compare. Look for whether the beginning, middle and end change in the same way. If you have a spectrogram, check whether the similar shape persists when you view the recordings at a comparable scale.

Now look at the accompanying information. If the recordings come from encounters with known whales, you may have a basis for comparing how two groups use the sound. If the second clip has no identification, it can still be interesting, but the similarity on its own leaves more possibilities open. Several groups can share features, and some sounds are hard to classify from a fragment. This is why researchers maintain reference recordings rather than naming whales from impressions of isolated clips.

If you share a clip, keep its source, date and description with it. A familiar sound may make someone curious about the whales, but the evidence available for a particular recording should determine the label you give it.

Frequently asked questions

Does every whale in a pod make exactly the same calls?

A pod's repertoire describes the call types documented for the group. It does not imply that all animals make every sound at the same time or with no variation. Researchers compare many recordings and account for the context before drawing conclusions about how calls are shared.

Can researchers tell what an individual call means?

They can look at what whales were doing when the sound was recorded and test whether it occurs more often in particular settings. A recurring association can be informative. It still takes more evidence to describe what the sound communicates in a given encounter. A dialect is mainly a description of recurring group patterns.

Do different pods ever share a call?

Yes. Similar calls or shared repertoires are one of the patterns researchers compare when grouping resident pods into acoustic clans. A sound shared by several pods may be useful for identifying a broader group, while giving less detail about which pod was present.

Can I listen from shore?

Human listeners cannot hear the underwater sound the way a hydrophone records it. Research groups such as OrcaLab provide feeds or archived recordings so you can listen remotely. Check the source's notes about the station, date and any identified whales.

On a tour or at home, start by describing what you can hear and then ask what the observation supports. The most interesting part may be how researchers connect the sound to a long record of familiar whales.