Back to the journal

How Rockfish Conservation Areas Protect Slow-Growing Coastal Fish

Rockfish among rocky reefs

British Columbia’s Rockfish Conservation Areas, or RCAs, reduce fishing pressure in places used by inshore rockfish. Many rockfish grow slowly, live for decades and take years to reproduce. Some are also vulnerable when brought to the surface from depth, even when a fisher plans to release them. Restrictions within a mapped area can reduce both targeted catch and incidental capture. Fisheries and Oceans Canada publishes the boundaries and the fishing restrictions that apply. DFO overview of rockfish and Rockfish Conservation Areas DFO restricted fishing areas

The boundary is usually invisible on the water. You might see the same rocky point and channel whether you’re inside or outside a closure. The distinction is visible on the official map, and the habitat the area is intended to cover can be well below the surface. That is part of what makes an RCA worth understanding even if you’re simply crossing the coast on a tour.

Why some rockfish take a long time to recover

Rockfish are a group of species with different habits and life histories. Inshore species such as yelloweye and quillback can be very long-lived. Slow growth and late maturity mean that replacing older fish takes time. If fishing removes adults faster than younger fish join the breeding population, a reduction in fishing pressure can help more fish survive. It may take years before a change becomes visible in the sizes and ages found at a site. DFO guidance on protecting inshore rockfish

Think about the life of one fish before considering the whole population. A young fish has to survive its early stages, settle into suitable habitat and grow. If the species takes years to mature, the number of fish seen soon after a closure says little about how many of those juveniles will reproduce. At the other end of the population, an older fish that survives can continue to contribute over time. The benefit of protection can therefore develop along a different timetable from the announcement of a boundary.

Inshore rockfish may occupy rocky reefs and other structured habitats. Some individuals can remain associated with particular areas for substantial periods. Restrictions can be especially relevant for animals that repeatedly use habitat within the boundary. Other fish move, and different life stages may depend on other places. A network spread across the coast can cover a range of conditions rather than trying to represent every species and life stage in one patch.

Why avoiding capture matters

When a rockfish is brought rapidly towards the surface, the reduction in pressure can cause gas in its swim bladder to expand. The injuries and effects of this pressure change are called barotrauma. An affected fish may have difficulty swimming back down on its own. DFO describes descending devices and requirements for returning incidentally caught rockfish to depth. An area restriction addresses the problem earlier by reducing fishing activities likely to encounter rockfish inside the boundary. DFO information on rockfish barotrauma and descending devices

Incidental catch matters because a person fishing for another species can still encounter rockfish. An RCA can restrict fishing methods that create that risk. If an activity is permitted in an area, its status depends on the current rules for that place and method. Check the relevant rules before fishing. DFO’s restrictions page and protected area maps explain which information belongs to the boundary and which belongs to the activity you are considering.

The two protections serve different situations. A closure reduces exposure to particular activities in a defined place. A descending device can help address the effects of capture when rockfish are caught incidentally where fishing is permitted. Those measures can work alongside catch restrictions, monitoring and stock assessment. A guide describing one should make clear which problem it addresses so readers can find the relevant DFO information.

How the area is tied to the habitat below

A conservation boundary can enclose reefs, kelp forests, eelgrass beds or other coastal habitat, depending on the location. Different species and sizes of fish can use different depths and structures. A deep rocky slope may hold fish that a shallow survey could miss. A patch of kelp near the surface can provide habitat for some young fish, while older fish of a species may use deeper ground. The amount of habitat suitable for a particular rockfish varies across areas. Study modelling rocky reef habitat in southern BC RCAs

Scientists have used information on catches, depths and seabed structure to plan and evaluate the network. A map of potential habitat helps identify likely reef inside and outside protected areas. A video survey can show the structure and fish visible along a particular line. The two views complement each other. A model can cover a broad area and guide where to look, while a survey gives observations from actual sections of the seabed. Research on developing BC’s inshore rockfish conservation strategy Field study of RCAs with a remotely operated vehicle

Imagine a boundary that includes one rocky ledge and a large area of sediment. Its total size on a chart is easy to measure. The amount of habitat suitable for a reef-associated fish is a different number. Another area may look smaller on the chart but contain a greater share of the type of reef the fish uses. This is why evaluations distinguish the area of the closure from the amount and distribution of relevant habitat within it.

What scientists can measure after a closure

A survey can count fish, estimate their density along a known area or compare their sizes. Researchers have used remotely operated vehicles to make observations on comparable habitat within and beside BC conservation areas. The surveys reach depths and terrain that can be hard to sample by other means. Comparable habitat matters because a rocky ledge and a sandy patch could hold different fish even if both had the same fishing history. DFO technical report on remotely operated vehicle surveys of BC RCAs

An early survey may detect little difference for a particular species. DFO’s evaluation of rebuilding strategies for inside yelloweye rockfish notes that some surveys found no difference in abundance or size inside RCAs at the time of study, several years after establishment. That result describes the surveyed places, time and fish. A later comparison can examine whether the pattern changes. Interpreting it may also require information about starting conditions, fishing activity, habitat and compliance. DFO evaluation of rebuilding strategies for inside yelloweye rockfish

Consider a reef that held few large fish when protection began. More juveniles could survive without producing a noticeable increase in large adults during the first few years. If another survey finds larger fish later, scientists still need comparable depth, habitat and methods to interpret the difference. A count of fish visible on the day and an estimate of long-term recovery answer different questions. Neither can be inferred from the mapped boundary alone.

Why the age of the fish is useful evidence

Two surveys can find the same number of rockfish and show a different pattern in size. One may record mostly small fish and the other a wider range that includes many large adults. The larger fish may represent individuals that survived for many years, depending on the species. A biologist can use the size information to decide whether to investigate age or recruitment more closely. If the surveys recorded only a total, that difference would disappear. For slow-growing species, the arrival of young fish and the persistence of old fish both matter to recovery.

There are limits to the comparison. Size varies among species and individuals, so a camera view alone does not always establish age. Underwater video can also be more effective at finding conspicuous fish than ones tucked into a crevice. Researchers can use calibrated equipment and comparable routes to reduce some sources of difference. They still need to interpret what they measured in light of what was visible. DFO’s video surveys compare habitats and document the sampling design so readers can see which fish and areas the observations describe.

Why the network can be reviewed over time

New maps can show reef that was not well described when an area was selected. Monitoring can also reveal differences in which depths and species are represented. DFO describes a review of the RCA network with goals that include representing a range of habitats used by inshore rockfish and lingcod. That is a question about whether the network covers the habitat it is intended to protect. The separate question of how the fish respond requires monitoring before and after measures, or other comparisons suited to the data.

If you read a proposal alongside a current closure map, keep their dates and purposes with them. A study might recommend adjusting an area because a reef extends beyond a line. The official map and notices tell you which boundary and restrictions currently apply. A review document can also describe areas by regional management unit, while a fishing map shows the smaller areas a person needs to identify before checking a particular restriction or opening.

How to check a location around Campbell River

Use Fisheries and Oceans Canada’s current map and area page. The agency’s page for BC tidal Area 13 covers Campbell River and nearby waters around islands including Quadra and Cortes. It lists restrictions and links to more detailed information. Locate the exact place and subarea first, then check the mapped RCA and the restriction for the activity and date. A familiar bay name or a point marked on an older map may cover more than one regulatory area. DFO tidal Area 13 fishing limits, openings and closures DFO maps of protected areas in the Canadian Pacific

An RCA may appear near other closures on the same map. Read the layer name and open the information for the actual boundary. The purpose and restrictions can differ across mapped areas. If you’re comparing two documents, check their dates and use the current DFO sources to verify what applies. The official recreational map user guide explains how to identify an area and view information on the restrictions associated with it. DFO guide to the Pacific recreational fishing regulations map

What a visitor can learn without going underwater

From shore or a boat, look for broad clues about the coast’s shape. A rocky point can continue below the water as reef. A visible kelp canopy can mark part of a bed while hiding the rock and fish below. Those observations help make sense of a map that highlights different habitats. They cannot establish the depth of a reef or the position of the legal boundary on their own. Eagle Eye Adventures’ guide to wildlife around Campbell River beyond whales provides context for the wildlife you can see above the same coastal habitats.

If you’re reading an RCA description, identify the fish or habitat it discusses and the period of any survey mentioned. A report of juvenile fish near kelp and a survey of large rockfish on deeper reef may describe different parts of the same ecosystem. Keeping the life stage and depth with the observation gives you a better sense of why the network includes different areas.

Does a closure mean the fish have already recovered?

A closure describes a management measure intended to reduce fishing pressure in a defined place. Recovery describes what the fish population does over time. It depends on survival, reproduction, habitat and other factors. Surveys can test for changes and provide information to refine management. A map can tell you where the measure applies. A study of fish, sizes or population trends can tell you what scientists have observed in the years since it began. DFO inside yelloweye rockfish rebuilding evaluation