A whale sighting map shows where people or instruments detected and recorded whales. A cluster can reflect frequent whale use, frequent observation or both. Before comparing two areas, check what a dot represents, how long the map collected records and whether it shows where people searched. An empty area can mean no whale was reported during that period. Without information on coverage and detection, it gives limited evidence about whether whales were absent. Researchers in British Columbia use sighting data and account for uneven observer effort when they investigate where cetaceans occur. Study of northeastern Pacific cetacean habitat suitability using citizen science data Ocean Wise Sightings Network
Suppose you see many points near Campbell River and fewer across another part of the coast. Start by reading the map’s legend rather than counting the points. The records may be reports of different groups, repeated observations of a few travelling animals or a measure that already accounts for where people looked. Those three interpretations can lead to very different conclusions.
Find out what a mark represents
A dot can be a single submission, an encounter recorded by a research team, a group consolidated from several reports or a location assigned to an identified individual. On some maps the point is placed at the observer’s position. On others it marks an estimated animal location. A map may also show colour in grid cells instead of individual points. Read the legend to see whether the colour means a count, a rate, a model result or a different measure. A darker cell gives you more of whatever the scale measures. You need the label to know what that is.
If a report contains six whales, the map might still display one dot. If six people report the same group, it might display several dots or merge them depending on the system. An animal that travels along a channel can also be reported at several locations within a short time. A count of map symbols therefore may be useful for describing how many reports a network received. It can be a poor way to count individual whales without a method to link reports and identify animals. Ocean Wise Whale Report user guide
Open a record if the interface allows it. Look for the species, time, number and confidence shown. One point might refer to a blow with uncertain identity and another to a group with confirmed photographs. A map can filter out uncertain records for a particular analysis. If a screenshot doesn’t include the filters, return to the original map before drawing a conclusion about the species shown.
Look for the places people searched
Observer effort describes where, when and how much people looked. A ferry route, a stretch of coast beside a community and the waters around a busy harbour can have many opportunities for a report. An exposed reach with few travellers can have fewer observers even when whales use it. Visibility also changes with fog, rain, light and sea state. Two groups of observers can spend similar amounts of time on the water and have different chances of detecting the same animal.
Imagine one coastal cell was watched for a hundred hours and produced ten reports. Another was watched for ten hours and produced four. The first cell has more reports. The second has more reports per hour in that simple comparison. The rate is still affected by what species were observed, how groups were counted and the conditions during each watch. Those invented numbers show how the same records can support different statements when you add information about effort.
Some maps include routes or layers for survey effort. Read them alongside the detections. A group of dots clustered along the route can show where animals and observers overlapped. A blank gap between the routes may have been outside the area people could see. If there is no effort layer or explanation, keep your conclusion limited to the records shown. You can say a whale was reported in one place without claiming it was more abundant there than elsewhere.
Check the time window and the delay
A map can cover an afternoon, a month or several years. Long periods can make rare events visible, but they combine records from different conditions and seasons. Shorter periods may better describe recent reports and show fewer encounters. Compare the same date ranges if you want to look across years or seasons. Check whether the map uses the date the animal was observed or the date a report was posted.
Some programmes restrict or delay public location information. Ocean Wise describes public regional views in its app as delayed and provides private real-time alerts to authorized users. A visible point is therefore an observation from the stated time, and a screenshot may circulate after the animal has moved. Use the time stamp and the map’s own description before calling a point recent. Ocean Wise FAQ on public sightings and private alerts
Reporting can also change with the season. A study using Ocean Wise records noted that many came from the southern BC coast in summer. That makes the database valuable for describing occurrences while raising a question about places and seasons with fewer observers. A winter map with fewer marks might reflect different animal distribution, fewer observers, different conditions or several of those factors.
Read an effort-adjusted map differently
A research team may divide sightings by survey effort or use a model to account for the places observers were more likely to visit. Fisheries and Oceans Canada’s work on Southern Resident killer whale summer distribution describes how researchers used vessel GPS tracks to approximate search effort in parts of the study. That gives the sightings additional context. The report also describes how the researchers treated different data sources and assumptions. An effort-adjusted result remains tied to those choices and the study area. DFO study of Southern Resident killer whale summer distribution and habitat use
A habitat suitability map uses a different approach. Researchers can combine occurrence records with environmental data and use a model to estimate conditions associated with the species. The model can provide information about areas with limited direct observations. The colours show model output, which differs from a map of sightings and from a count of animals. Read which environmental variables and observations went into it and how the authors assessed the result.
A formal abundance estimate asks how many animals occupy a defined area during a period. Producing one typically takes information about coverage, how animals are detected and how repeated observations are handled. If a map’s legend says sightings, keep using that word. If it says predicted suitability, describe the prediction. Use a population estimate when the question concerns how many animals were present and a study actually estimated that quantity.
Compare two coastal areas without overstating the map
Start with two areas of roughly comparable size and the same date range. Apply the same species and confidence filters. Ask whether the map shows comparable observation routes or whether one area includes a busy reporting corridor. Check whether both have similar access and visibility. If you can’t establish comparable effort, describe where reports concentrate and name the limit. “More reports appeared near this route during the period shown” is different from saying more whales lived there.
If both areas were surveyed under a defined protocol, check the unit used in the comparison. Sightings per unit of effort can be more informative than counts, provided the methods and conditions can reasonably be compared. A rate based on boat hours is different from one based on distance travelled. A map of groups also differs from one showing individual whales. You can often tell which statement is supportable by copying the map’s exact units into your notes.
A change in scale can change the visual impression. Dots crowded at a wide map scale may separate when you zoom in, and a software cluster can combine several points into one symbol. A broad grid can pool parts of a channel with different habitat and use. Check whether the patterns you notice persist when you view a finer scale, and read how the map groups reports before treating a bold symbol as a large group of animals.
Check whether the map shows presence, density or probability
Presence tells you a whale was observed in a place during the period shown. Density refers to how many animals are estimated per unit of area. Probability in a model can mean several things, including the estimated chance that suitable conditions or the animals themselves occur. A map may use a scale from low to high without stating a number of whales. The accompanying method should explain what the scale means. Copy its label before trying to translate the shading into a statement about abundance.
Suppose a well-travelled channel has many points on a sightings map. A nearby stretch shows a high suitability value in a separate model. Both can offer evidence about the area, but they do so in different ways. The points represent records and the suitability value comes from the model’s relationship between occurrences and environmental conditions. If you quote both, keep their time periods and spatial scales separate. A cell may include more water than the channel visible from a single shore viewpoint, especially when a regional model uses a broad grid for the whole coast.
A comparison of two species needs similar care. A large blow can draw attention in conditions where a small porpoise goes unnoticed. If one species has more reports, that could reflect the number of animals, their visibility or how reliably observers identify them. Check whether a study accounted for detection differently for each species. A map filtered to an easily seen whale and one filtered to a more inconspicuous animal can look different even when both species share much of the area.
Use the map to prepare for an observation
A sightings map can help you learn the geography of the area and the species that have been reported. It can show you the names of channels and places where observers have logged encounters. It cannot promise a sighting during a particular outing. Eagle Eye Adventures’ guide to marine wildlife around Campbell River gives context for the animals you may be able to recognise if one comes into view.
If you contribute a report, keep the actual observation time and use the best location you can give for the animal. Record uncertainty about species or group size. A clear photograph from a lawful, safe distance can help identify a whale, while a wide view may help locate the encounter. Use the programme’s reporting instructions and let the animal continue without trying to follow a point on a map. DFO marine mammal sighting and reporting guidance
What can a blank space tell you?
On a public sighting map, it may show that the selected filters returned no reports for that area. If the area was surveyed, check the tracks, dates and conditions to see whether an animal would likely have been detected. A blank during a defined survey carries different information from a blank in water no one visited. Even with coverage, an animal could be underwater or difficult to see. Keep the conclusion tied to the data. The blank is a useful place to ask how the map was made before you decide what it says about whales.
