From shore, look for a dorsal fin on a humpback and a low hump followed by a row of knuckles on a grey whale. A humpback can also show long pectoral flippers and a broad fluke with an irregular trailing edge. A grey whale often appears mottled and can show a low, bushy blow that looks heart-shaped from some angles. Wind and distance can change the look of a blow. A clear view of the back, or a second feature on the same animal, usually provides a stronger identification. DFO grey whale species profile NOAA Fisheries humpback whale profile NOAA Fisheries grey whale profile
You may notice the blow before the whale. Pick a landmark or section of open water and wait for the body to appear. If the animal surfaces several times, watch the order in which its head, back and tail come into view. Each surfacing may show a different part of the whale. A single wave can hide the feature you need.
Start with the back
On a humpback, look for a distinct dorsal fin, which can be small and variable in shape. It sits well back on the body. As the whale arches to dive, the back around the fin can become more conspicuous. A quick view of the front of the whale can miss the fin entirely. Wait for the body to roll farther through the water before making anything of its absence. DFO British Columbia cetacean identification poster
A grey whale has no true dorsal fin. It has a low dorsal hump and a series of bumps, or knuckles, between the hump and the tail. A side view can reveal that sequence as the animal surfaces and curves down. The knuckles may be hard to resolve from a high or head-on view. If a low ridge is visible but the water hides the tail stock, record that part of the view as incomplete. A humpback’s dorsal fin can look like a low bump in a poor view.
The best comparison is often a sequence rather than a frame. A frame that shows the clearest blow may show little of the whale’s back. The next frames could reveal the dorsal region. If you are watching with binoculars, follow the back towards the tail as it rolls. Keep enough water in view to let the animal move without losing the section where it surfaced.
Use the blow as a cue to look again
A grey whale’s blow is often described as low and bushy. It can look heart-shaped when viewed from ahead or behind. A humpback can also produce a bushy blow. The position of the observer, weather and the direction in which the whale exhales influence the visible shape. A steady breeze can push vapour sideways before you get a clear look. A distant view can also make a wide blow look like a single column. NOAA Fisheries whale identification illustrations and descriptions
Try to place the blow and the body in the same sequence. If you see a heart-shaped blow followed by a long back without a distinct fin and then a row of knuckles, the observations support one another. If the blow is all you saw, call it a blow. The next surfacing may reveal more useful features. Another large whale could be travelling in the same general area, so keep track of where each blow appears and which back follows it.
Light can make the same blow look different against water, trees or sky. A low cloud of vapour can remain visible against a dark shore while disappearing into a pale sky. If you are comparing photographs, check the angle and background. The apparent outline can change between the first moment of exhalation and the time the vapour starts to drift. That is another reason to treat blow shape as supporting evidence.
Compare the colour, flippers and flukes
Grey whales often show mottled skin, including patches associated with barnacles and whale lice. A good view of the flank can reveal light areas across the body. A humpback generally looks darker, with variable lighter areas on the flippers and underside. Reflections and foam can make either animal appear patchy from a distance. If a mark remains in the same position when the whale turns, it is stronger evidence than one pale flash at the waterline. NOAA Fisheries humpback whale profile
A humpback’s pectoral flipper can be particularly useful when the animal rolls far enough to reveal it. The flippers can reach about one-third of the whale’s length. A grey whale has shorter, broader flippers relative to its body. If you see only a fin tip, perspective can make the comparison difficult. Look for where the shape joins the body and whether it remains in view through the roll.
Both whales can lift their tail flukes when they dive. A humpback can show an irregular trailing edge and variable black and white pigmentation on the underside. A grey whale has broad flukes, a deep central notch and a smoother, curved outline. A notch in the middle alone is therefore a weak separation. Look at the edge and colour across both lobes if visible, and compare them with the back you saw before the dive. DFO humpback whale catalogue NOAA Fisheries grey whale physical description
Use location as supporting context
Grey whales often use shallow coastal waters, including areas along western Vancouver Island. Some feed along the Pacific coast instead of continuing to northern feeding areas. Humpbacks also occur in coastal British Columbia and can appear in channels and near shore as well as in more open water. A whale’s distance from land can help you think of possible species. The dorsal profile and body details are more useful for deciding which animal you actually saw. COSEWIC North Pacific humpback whale assessment
The coast’s shape can distort distance. A whale seen in front of a point may actually be well beyond it. A blow against the dark background of an island can be visible much farther away than you expect. Use a fixed point to describe the direction and note if you could only estimate the distance. Species that use the outer coast or inland channels can still be difficult to distinguish when the view is brief.
It also helps to keep habitat and behaviour separate. A whale swimming a steady line close to shore could be travelling. A whale repeatedly rolling in one patch could be using a feeding area. Without a view of the mouth, prey or surrounding conditions, leave the behaviour open. Even a useful habitat clue may say more about what is possible there than what the whale was doing during the moments you saw it.
Work through two limited views
First, imagine you see a blow and then a dark back that arches high, showing a distinct fin. A few seconds later the flukes lift and show a variable pale underside and an irregular edge. Those features support humpback. If the fin appeared only as a shadow and the flukes were hidden, keep the identification as possible and see if another surfacing improves the view.
Now picture a whale travelling in relatively shallow water. You see a pale mottled flank, a low hump and several knuckles farther back as the animal rolls. Those observations support grey whale. If you only saw a pale patch and a low blow, the same location and movement would leave more room for other species. This is the difference between a combination of marks and a pair of cues that wind and light can easily change.
If another whale surfaces nearby, keep its marks separate. A whale with a low dorsal outline can be travelling close to one with a more distinct fin. A photograph showing both animals can help you establish which one had which feature. If you only have close crops, check their times and compare the direction each animal was facing. A strong identification needs the marks on the same whale.
When glare or distance takes away the colour
A dark shoreline can make a pale blow easy to find and a dark dorsal fin hard to see. Turn the comparison around when the animal moves into open water. The fin may become clearer as a silhouette, while the blow disappears against bright sky. Use the light to decide which feature to look for. A silhouette is good for an outline and poor for judging pigmentation. If the sea is choppy, several surfacings may be needed to see the full length of the back.
In binoculars, the field of view is narrower than the area you can watch with your unaided eyes. Find a point or other fixed feature near the last surfacing before lifting them. Keep some open water in view in the animal’s likely direction of travel. If the whale surfaces at an unexpected angle, you can return to the wider view and pick it up again. There is no need to move onto an exposed rock or down the shore to improve a brief identification.
When comparing a photograph with the DFO poster, identify which part of the illustration corresponds to your view. A side illustration shows the dorsal region and knuckles together. Your photo may show only the top of a whale that was heading away. Look for visible agreement and mark the rest as unseen. If a clear later frame shows the end of the back, check whether there is a fin or a row of knuckles and then compare the colour if the light allows. A few careful comparisons can give you a defensible species identification even with a long viewing distance.
What to record from a public viewpoint
Write down the time, general location, direction of travel and the clearest part of the body. Add the water and light conditions. If you saw only the back, describe how much of it was visible and whether the area near the tail was hidden. A note such as “dark back arched, distinct small fin, tail stayed below water” gives an observer a starting point. If you saw no fin because waves blocked the back, say that rather than describing a whale with no fin.
A photograph can help when you keep the water around the whale in view. A wide frame preserves where it surfaced and whether other animals were nearby. If the animal dives, scan ahead and to either side of where you last saw it. Do that from a stable public viewpoint. You can let the whale pass and still have a good record of a short encounter. Eagle Eye Adventures’ guide to marine wildlife around Campbell River introduces other cetaceans and marine animals that may appear in the same waters.
What if the two species still seem possible?
Keep the identification as a large whale or give the likely alternatives with the evidence you had. You may have seen enough to recognise a baleen whale’s back and blow without being able to see the fin, knuckles or flukes. If you contribute a sighting to a research programme, include the view, time, location and any images. A reviewer may be able to recognise details you missed or reach the same tentative conclusion. Both outcomes preserve what you actually saw. DFO marine mammal sighting guidance
