British Columbia’s five Pacific salmon are Chinook, coho, chum, pink and sockeye. Tail spots offer a useful first comparison. Chinook and pink salmon can show spots on both tail lobes. Coho spots are usually concentrated on the upper lobe, while chum and sockeye generally lack tail spots. The shape of the tail, the colour of the gums and the fish’s spawning appearance can help confirm the identification. If you’re watching fish from a bank, expect to see only some of those features. Fisheries and Oceans Canada salmon identification guide
Start by deciding what your view lets you judge. A photograph taken broadside may show the whole tail and the shape of the body. A view looking straight down through moving water may show the back, a flash of the side and almost nothing of the mouth. A fish that has already changed into spawning colours can look different from a silver fish of the same species in coastal water. Use a reference image from the closest life stage you can find. DFO Pacific salmon species accounts
Chinook salmon
Look for spots on the back and both tail lobes, a silvery tail in the marine phase and a dark mouth with black gums if the mouth is visible. Chinook can grow large, which is useful context when you can see the fish well. Two fish of different ages or at different distances can appear similar in size. Use the tail and mouth rather than trying to identify Chinook by size alone. Spawning fish may turn olive-brown to dark, changing the overall contrast of the markings.
The closest comparison in a spotted tail is often pink salmon. Both can show spots above and below the centre of the tail. In pink salmon, the spots tend to be large ovals, and the tail lacks the silvery look DFO describes for Chinook. If you have a clear image of the mouth, DFO describes Chinook’s mouth as dark with black gums and pink salmon’s mouth as white with black gums. The colour of the gum line and the colour inside the mouth are separate observations. A dark opening in shadow leaves both uncertain.
Coho salmon
A coho’s tail is comparatively square, with spots usually on the upper lobe. The base of the tail is relatively wide. Spots can also appear on the upper body. The gums are white, even though the mouth can have a dark edge. If a silver fish shows scattered spots above and a clear view of a mostly unspotted lower tail, coho becomes a good species to consider.
Returning coho can develop a red body and a dark or greenish head. That can look similar to the familiar red and green pattern of sockeye. If both fish are spawning, take another look at the back and tail rather than relying on which one seems redder. A clear view of coho’s upper spots supports the identification. If the fish is facing away and the upper lobe is lost in glare, you can record the colour and wait for a better angle.
Chum salmon
Chum generally lack black spots on the back and tail. In a fresh silver fish, look for silvery streaks on the tail, a narrow tail base and, if visible, a white tip on the anal fin. The anal fin is on the underside behind the belly. It can be hard to see from above. DFO also describes large teeth and a white mouth, with a tongue that may be dark.
As chum mature for spawning, vertical bands can become conspicuous on the sides, including reddish-purple bands on some males. At a suitable bank viewpoint, you may catch the bands as a fish turns, even when the tail is hidden. The bands can look subdued on a fish that is still silvery or in dark water. A big male may have very prominent teeth and a changed jaw profile. Try to place those clues alongside the bands and lack of tail spots rather than identifying any fish with a pronounced jaw as chum.
Pink salmon
Pink salmon typically show large oval spots on the back and both tail lobes. The tail is V-shaped and DFO describes it as lacking the silver colour used to help identify Chinook and coho. Pink salmon tend to be smaller than the other four species. In a clear spawning view, the pronounced hump on a mature male can be conspicuous. The nickname humpback salmon refers to that seasonal profile. Females and fish earlier in the migration won’t give you the same hump to look for.
Pink salmon have a two-year life cycle, a useful detail when you are learning about runs in a particular river. Timing can support an identification when there is reliable information for that location. It cannot give you a tail pattern on a fish you didn’t see clearly. Different systems have their own run histories, and fish of another species can pass through a reach during the same broader period. Start with the marks you could observe and use the local run as background.
Sockeye salmon
Sockeye lack spots on the back and tail. The tail is moderately forked and the mouth and gum line are pale. DFO also notes their prominent eyes. Before spawning, sockeye in the ocean can be silvery. The red body and greenish head associated with spawning sockeye are striking when well developed, but an earlier stage may show little of that contrast.
A red body makes sockeye worth considering when you watch a spawning run. Confirm which parts of the fish you can see and whether they show spots. A coho may also look red with a greenish head, but you may find spots on its upper body and tail. If you’re comparing a silver sockeye with chum, both can have a tail without black spots. Tail shape and streaking, plus the appearance of the sides and the other fins, can provide the second clue.
Work with the features you can actually see
From a bank, look for a fish holding in a shallow stretch where the water clears between ripples. Start with the back and follow its outline to the tail. Check whether the tail lobes are both visible. A dark mark at the top tells you little about whether spots extend to the lower lobe if the lower part remains in shadow. The fish may turn far enough for you to see both lobes briefly. If you are taking photos, a short sequence can preserve that turn better than a tightly framed single image.
Body colour needs an equally careful look. A moving salmon can look silver as it tilts towards the light and dark as it turns away. A vertical band belongs to the body if it stays in the same place as the fish changes angle. Reflections can sweep across several fish at once. When the light makes colour unreliable, pay attention to fixed markings and proportions. You may have enough evidence for one fish in a group and only a general impression of the others.
A natural view of the mouth can be rare. Use gum colour when the feature is already visible, for example in a clear reference photograph. The riverbank comparison usually rests on the tail, back, sides and spawning profile. Juvenile salmon can have other markings and proportions, including the vertical marks seen on parr. Use a juvenile-specific reference for small fish instead of applying adult tail and colour comparisons to every fish in the stream.
Try three common comparisons
Imagine an adult salmon with a dark back, obvious spots on both tail lobes and a silvery tail. The pattern points toward Chinook, especially if the mouth appears dark. If the spots are large ovals on a V-shaped tail and the fish shows a distinct shoulder hump in freshwater, pink is the stronger possibility. A view of both tail lobes provides more information than a quick estimate of size in either case.
In another reach, you spot a red salmon with a greenish head. Ask whether the tail has spots. Look for a square outline and marks concentrated toward the upper lobe for coho, or a moderately forked unspotted tail and an unspotted back for sockeye. A side view that shows the fish’s markings is more useful than deciding which shade of red you saw from farther away. If both fish are partly hidden, “red spawning salmon” is a fair description until more detail comes into view.
In a third observation, a large fish has an unspotted tail and darker vertical bands on its flanks. Those features support chum, particularly if the bands are well defined and you can see the tail narrow where it meets the body. If the bands belong to reflected shadows from a bridge, they may slide across the fish or appear in the same place as other fish swim through. Watch them against the fish’s movement before deciding what you saw.
Why fish of the same species can look different
Returning fish can change colour and shape as they mature. An individual that still looks silver can swim in the same area as another of its species with much stronger spawning colour. Mature males of some species can develop a pronounced hump or altered jaw, while a female in the same reach may have a less conspicuous profile. If you compare both fish with a picture of one mature male, you can miss the features they share. Look for tail markings or another feature the reference shows for more than one phase.
Try reading the reference picture in the same direction as the fish you saw. If the fish was facing upstream and you only saw its back, compare the width of the tail base and the distribution of marks along the visible upper body. A reference side view can prepare you for what might appear on the next turn, but it includes features your current angle may hide. Mark those as unseen. If the photographs show adult males and females separately, compare your sighting with both before dismissing a candidate species.
What to note after a coastal BC sighting
Record the date, general location and the visible features that supported your identification. “Two salmon, one with large spots on both tail lobes and a pronounced hump” preserves the evidence for pink without assigning the second fish to the same species. If the best view was a video, note which moment shows the tail. A still frame can reveal the markings and a wider clip can show which fish you were following. Leave fish in the water and observe from a public viewpoint that keeps you out of the channel.
Salmon connect the coast’s marine and freshwater habitats, and their presence can affect which wildlife you see nearby. Eagle Eye Adventures’ guide to Campbell River wildlife beyond whales describes other coastal animals to watch for. If you see birds or mammals near a run, keep your fish identification and your observation of the predator separate. A bird taking a fish shows a feeding event. A species identification still depends on the view you had of the fish itself.
