Back to the journal

What Happens When Orcas Take Fish From Fishing Gear

A fishing reel secured to a boat rail overlooking coastal water, no people or wildlife

When an orca takes a fish from fishing gear, researchers and fisheries managers call it depredation. Fisheries and Oceans Canada has received reports involving killer whales and sperm whales in British Columbia fisheries, including groundfish longline, salmon troll and recreational fishing. It matters because an animal can learn to associate fishing activity with food, and close contact with gear can injure or entangle it. If you are fishing, use DFO's current instructions for your fishery and report an incident. If you're watching from a guided wildlife boat, tell the crew what you saw and give the animals room. DFO Pacific depredation guidance

Understand what the word describes

Depredation has a specific meaning here. A whale removes fish from fishing gear. A whale catching a free-swimming fish near a boat is natural hunting. A whale appearing in the same area as a fishing vessel does not by itself establish either activity. Distinguishing them can be difficult from shore or another boat, especially if the fish and the gear are below the surface. Record what you could actually see before assigning a name to the encounter.

Imagine a fisher brings up gear and finds a fish missing. That observation might prompt a question about depredation, but it leaves room for other explanations. A whale may have been visible, the line may have moved and a fish may have come loose. If the fisher saw a whale take the fish from the line, the record is stronger. It helps to keep the circumstances and the level of certainty together when reporting the event.

Feeding a whale is a separate action. DFO warns against feeding marine mammals directly or indirectly, including by discarding fish or offal around them. The Marine Mammal Regulations address feeding as a form of disturbance. If you are aboard a wildlife boat, keep food, fishing gear and waste under the crew's control. The crew should be able to manage the encounter without passengers trying to attract an animal. Marine Mammal Regulations

Why a food reward can change later encounters

DFO describes depredation as a learned behaviour that can spread through a social group. A whale that obtains a fish from gear may encounter a similar opportunity another day. If the association is reinforced, the animal may return to fishing activity when it has a chance to get food. Other whales can be present during those events. The agency emphasises preventing the behaviour from becoming established because it is difficult to eliminate once learned.

This does not mean that a whale near a fishing vessel has learned to take catch. Marine mammals and fishers can both use waters where fish are present. A whale can pass nearby without interacting with the gear. A record that distinguishes repeated gear contact, approach and ordinary presence gives managers more information than one label applied to every nearby sighting.

The learning question also differs from the diet question. Fish-eating resident killer whales and mammal-eating Bigg’s killer whales are distinct Northeast Pacific ecotypes. Knowing that an animal is an orca does not settle what it was doing near fishing gear. If observers can identify the individuals or group, that can add context to a report. If they cannot, the event can still be described without guessing. Canadian killer whale status assessment · Eagle Eye guide to orca diet

What is at stake for whales and fishers

For a fisher, the immediate effect may be a lost catch. DFO also lists gear damage, additional time and costs, and reduced use of otherwise productive fishing areas. Those effects depend on the gear, place and number of interactions. A clear report helps people understand whether a problem is happening occasionally or repeatedly in a particular setting.

For the whale, being close to fishing gear can create the risk of injury, entanglement or gear ingestion. Entanglement is a different event from taking fish. If you see line on a whale or suspect it is injured, treat that as a possible incident and use the official reporting channel. Keep a safe distance and avoid trying to remove the gear. Notify the crew if you are a passenger. DFO Pacific incident reporting

There can also be effects beyond one encounter. DFO discusses the possibility of changes to feeding behaviour and movement if whales repeatedly learn to get fish from human activity. That is a reason to prevent food rewards where possible. It does not tell you how a particular whale's range will change. Long records help researchers compare what is happening in different fisheries and whether the same individuals are involved.

Follow the instructions for your role

If you are fishing

Read DFO's current advice and the rules for your fishery before going out. The agency's Pacific guidance advises fishers to avoid setting or hauling gear around whales and to avoid discarding fish or offal in their presence. It also gives guidance specific to groundline gear. Use the applicable official instructions rather than applying a procedure from one gear type to another. The skipper or person responsible for the fishing operation should manage the situation.

When you report an incident, provide what you know about the date, time, approximate location and type of fishing involved. Describe how the gear was being used, what the whale did and what you could see happen to the fish. If the whale's identification is uncertain, say that. If you have an original photo or video, keep it available and ask how to submit it. DFO lists its Pacific incident number and reporting options in the depredation guidance.

If you are a passenger or watching from shore

Tell the crew if you are on a guided vessel and see what might be an interaction with gear. They may have a better view and can decide how to handle the observation. If you are on shore, stay at the public viewing location and note what you can see. A brief record can describe the whales, the vessel and the sequence without asserting a contact you could not verify. Follow DFO's official guidance for reporting an incident.

Keep a routine sighting separate from an incident report. A whale travelling near a boat may be an observation worth recording, but a photo caption should not accuse anyone of feeding it without evidence. If you saw an interaction that concerns you, let the official reporting process collect the details. A public post can repeat the claim without the context a reviewer needs.

Compare three situations you might encounter

A whale surfaces near a boat retrieving gear. You saw the whale, the vessel and the retrieval. If you did not see the whale contact the gear or take a fish, say so. This can still be useful context for an operator or a report. It is different from observing a fish taken directly off a line. Record the order of events before drawing a conclusion.

A fisher sees a whale take a fish from the gear. That observation fits the DFO description of depredation. Follow the current guidance for the fishery and report it. Record what type of gear was in use and whether any remained attached to the whale. If you suspect entanglement, raise that concern through the incident channel. Avoid creating another opportunity for the animal to obtain food.

A whale appears with line trailing from its body. Treat it as a possible entanglement. If you are on a guided boat, tell the crew immediately. Report the location and what the line looked like if you can do so safely. Keep your distance and follow the instructions of the responding authorities. A visible line does not tell you how the animal first contacted the gear. The immediate priority is sharing information that can help assess the incident.

Ask how evidence is used across reports

If multiple people observed the same event, their accounts can complement one another. One person may have seen the fish and another may have noted the location. They should each describe what they observed. If a guide or fisher collected other details, you can mention who has them rather than stating that you personally verified them. This helps a reviewer identify what is confirmed and what still needs checking.

Repeated reports can help managers ask where and when depredation occurs. A period with more reports can mean more interactions, better reporting or a change in fishing activity. A period with few reports does not necessarily show that it stopped. Fisheries and Oceans Canada emphasises reporting and monitoring because the problem is hard to measure from a single encounter.

Notice where the gear and the animal were in the sequence

For a report, it helps to say whether the gear was being set, left in the water or retrieved when you first noticed the whale. The fisher may know details that are invisible to someone watching from another vessel. A passenger can note the point at which the whale appeared and what changed afterwards. Those accounts can work together without treating every observer as though they saw the same event from the same angle. If you did not see the fish come out of the water, leave that detail open.

If you have a clip, retain the part before the apparent interaction if the recording captured it. The approach, the boat's activity and the position of the gear may all matter. A short excerpt that starts after a splash can be useful, but it may leave the sequence uncertain. Keep the time and location with the original file so it can be compared with other notes. If your phone recorded the boat's position and you were some distance away, explain that difference in the report.

A complete note can be modest. For example, you might record that two fins were visible while a nearby boat retrieved gear, that one whale changed direction and that you could not see a fish. Someone else may have direct evidence of an interaction. If nobody does, the record can still describe a whale near fishing activity without calling it confirmed depredation. That distinction makes reports more useful when an agency is comparing incidents across different gear types and locations.

Frequently asked questions

Does every fish missing from a line count as depredation?

A missing fish can have several explanations. A confirmed observation of a whale taking it from gear provides stronger evidence than a missing catch with a whale nearby. If you are uncertain, describe the observations and let the report reflect the uncertainty.

Can I use a deterrent if whales approach?

Follow current DFO advice for the fishery and Canada's marine mammal rules. DFO warns against feeding or disturbing whales and specifically addresses acoustic deterrents in its guidance. Ask the agency about the lawful procedure that applies to the gear and situation.

Is this the same as a whale catching its own salmon?

Natural prey capture is part of the whale's ecology. Depredation refers to removing fish from fishing gear. If the capture happened out of view, keep the description open. A guide can help explain what evidence would distinguish the two.

Should I report a possible entanglement even if I am unsure?

Use DFO's Pacific incident guidance and describe exactly what you could see. Include the location and time. If you are a passenger, notify the crew. Let the people responsible for the response assess the situation and decide what happens next.

On a Campbell River trip, listen to how the naturalist distinguishes an observed event from an interpretation about prey or gear. That is a useful way to learn about both whale behaviour and the work of keeping the animals safe. Eagle Eye Campbell River whale watching