Bigg’s killer whales often hunt quietly because many of the marine mammals they pursue can hear underwater. A seal, sea lion or porpoise that detects an approaching whale may have an opportunity to move away. Researchers comparing fish-eating and mammal-eating killer whales in the Northeast Pacific found differences in their use of sound during foraging. Quiet hunting means making fewer detectable sounds in some contexts. Bigg’s killer whales can still call and echolocate. A quiet hydrophone recording alone cannot tell you that a hunt is underway or identify the whales nearby. Barrett-Lennard and colleagues on sonar use
A hunting sound can help the whale and alert its prey
When an orca produces an echolocation click, it can gain information from echoes that come back. The returning sound may help it detect or investigate an object. The original sound can also travel to other animals. If a prey animal can hear it, the signal that gives the whale information can also give its target information. That trade-off helps explain why the sound patterns of orcas that search for fish can differ from those of orcas that hunt marine mammals.
The important distinction is the kind of prey and what that prey can detect. A mammal-eating group might be looking for a harbour seal resting near shore or a porpoise moving in open water. Those animals face different situations and may respond differently. The research supports an explanation for broad patterns in sound use, without making a prediction about the response of every animal or the actions of every hunting group. Canadian killer whale status assessment
Imagine listening to a familiar sound in a quiet room. The moment you hear it, you can turn your attention towards the source. A marine mammal's underwater hearing operates in a different environment, but the example explains why detectable sounds can affect behaviour. In the wild, direction, distance, background noise and the frequency of the signal can all influence what another animal hears. A study needs to establish more than the fact that whales and prey share a body of water.
Quiet hunting changes with the phase of the encounter
A hunt has several parts. A group can travel towards an area, search, approach, pursue prey, handle it and then move on or socialise. Which part an observer sees can change the description of the entire encounter. A group that is quiet while travelling can be heard later. A call recorded after a visible interaction can add context without showing what the whales were doing in the minutes before it. NOAA Fisheries killer whale science
The animals can also be spread out. From a tour boat you may see one fin while other members of the group remain below the surface or farther away. If you hear a call at the same time, avoid assigning it to the whale you can see. A sound can travel from outside the immediate view. Researchers use the circumstances of the recording and known individuals to decide how much the evidence supports.
Quiet hunting is sometimes described as stealth. That is a useful description of the possible advantage of limiting sound during an approach. It does not require the observer to explain the intention behind every movement. A group may move slowly for several reasons. It may change direction because of prey, because another animal surfaced or because of something the observer cannot see. Describe the sequence before trying to give it a name.
How scientists compare noisy and quiet encounters
Researchers studying foraging use observations of known whales and recordings of their sounds. The key is connecting a recording with a particular context. If the observers can recognise the ecotype, see what the whales are doing and record when the sounds occur, they can compare similar parts of encounters. Repeating the comparison across many observations makes it easier to distinguish a pattern from an unusually quiet or loud day.
The researcher also needs to consider whether the equipment would have recorded the sound. A hydrophone measures what reaches it. A whale may be facing away, travelling out of range or producing sounds that are difficult to distinguish from background noise. If two recordings were made at different distances or under different conditions, comparing the number of audible signals directly can be misleading. Read the methods when a study claims that one group clicked less than another.
An observation of prey can help establish what was happening. For example, a researcher might see a group pursue a marine mammal and match that sequence to an audio record. Another recording might contain sounds from a known group but provide little evidence about what it was doing. The first can help test a question about hunting behaviour. The second is still useful for acoustic monitoring, but it answers a different question.
What fish-eating resident whales contribute to the comparison
Resident killer whales feed on fish and rely heavily on Chinook salmon in British Columbia. Research on resident hunting shows how sounds and movements can be studied together. That evidence helps explain how an animal may investigate a target that is below the surface. It also provides a comparison with Bigg’s, whose prey includes other mammals. The comparison works best when the researchers know which animals and activities they are recording. NOAA Fisheries on Southern Resident hunting · Eagle Eye orca diet guide
Avoid turning the difference into a rule that residents are always loud and Bigg’s are always silent. A resident group can spend time without making signals that reach a listener. Bigg’s have recorded calls and can use sound in contexts that differ from a quiet search. The studies describe tendencies across documented encounters. You would need more information to interpret a few minutes of audio from one boat or a shore station.
This distinction also keeps the idea of dialect separate from foraging. A dialect describes recurring call patterns associated with a group. Quiet searching concerns the rate and circumstances in which sounds are produced and detected. Both can be studied with hydrophones, but they are not interchangeable. If you hear a guide use one term, ask whether they are describing the shape of the sound, the amount of sound or what the animals were doing at the time.
Listen for what the guide can actually establish
On a Campbell River outing, ask whether the guide knows which animals are present and what led to that identification. They may recognise a dorsal fin or saddle patch, or there may be too little detail. If the hydrophone is quiet, ask what conditions affect the listening. The answer might have to do with the animals, the receiver or other sounds. Treat each of those as a possible explanation until you know more. Eagle Eye Campbell River orca guide
If you see seals and killer whales in the same area, watch what happens before deciding there is a hunt. Note whether the whales approach, pass or turn and whether you can see what the seals do. An animal may disappear from view while the boat stays in the same place. It is fine to describe the encounter without concluding why the animal moved. The view from the surface can show only part of the interaction.
Give wildlife room and follow the crew's viewing instructions. If a sighting changes quickly, the best contribution you can make is to pay attention from your assigned position. A close photograph is unnecessary for learning about the soundscape. A wide view or a short note can help you remember the context later, even when you did not hear a call. Fisheries and Oceans Canada viewing guidance
Compare two explanations for the same quiet interval
Suppose you hear several short sounds, then a quiet interval while the whales are still visible. One possibility is that they stopped making those sounds. Another is that they turned or moved in a way that changed what reached the receiver. If the boat's engine or another source of noise changed at the same time, it may also affect what you heard. A recording helps narrow the possibilities when it can be compared with observations and the conditions.
Now suppose a guide recognises a family of Bigg’s killer whales and later sees them interacting with prey. That adds evidence about who was present and what happened after the quiet interval. It can still be difficult to know exactly when searching became pursuit or which whale made a particular sound. Ask how those limits are handled in a study. They are part of interpreting the result, not a reason to ignore what the researchers did see.
A useful observation can therefore be modest. Record the date, approximate location and which animals were visible. Note whether the sound was heard from a hydrophone and whether the guide identified it. If you only remember that it was quiet while the whales were in view, describe that as an observation rather than proof of hunting. It can still make you pay more attention to how a different encounter unfolds.
Consider how prey, place and group size change the question
A harbour seal near a rocky shore and a porpoise travelling through a channel create different observation problems for researchers. At the shore, the observer may be able to see both the whale and the potential prey for part of the encounter. In open water, one or both animals may disappear below the surface before their movements can be followed. A quiet recording is more informative when the observer can say which animals were present and what part of the encounter it covers.
Group size adds another question. A few whales can be separated by a considerable stretch of water, even if they are travelling together. If one whale is in clear view, a sound may still come from another member of the group. A group spread out along the coast can also change its position relative to the recorder without making an obvious change in activity. Researchers can compare observations made at known times and locations to see whether a particular pattern repeats.
These details matter when comparing encounters on different days. If the prey, group and recording circumstances all differ, a change in the amount of sound may have several explanations. The research finding comes from the pattern across encounters, supported by what the observers knew about the animals and their behaviour.
Frequently asked questions
Are Bigg’s killer whales silent all the time?
They make calls and can use echolocation. The research compares when mammal-eating and fish-eating killer whales use sound during particular activities. Bigg’s often limit detectable sound while foraging, which is different from never making a sound.
Can a seal detect every killer whale click?
What another animal can detect depends on the signal, background noise, distance and the hearing of that animal. The possibility of being heard is part of the explanation researchers examine. It doesn't establish that a particular seal heard a click in an encounter you watched.
Can a guide tell me what the whales are hunting?
Sometimes there is visible evidence or other context that supports an explanation. Often much of the action is underwater. Ask the guide what they observed and which details remain uncertain. You can learn about the hunt without identifying the prey.
Will I hear the difference on a whale watching tour?
A hydrophone may record signals in suitable conditions. A short recording on its own may not distinguish the ecotype or activity. Ask what the guide knows about the whales and whether sound, photographs or behaviour helped them recognise the group.
On a Campbell River wildlife trip, listen for how the crew ties a sound or a quiet interval to what they can see. The evidence behind the interpretation is often as interesting as the encounter itself. Eagle Eye six-hour whale watching tour
